‘The Best Christmas Pageant Ever’ a Holiday Must-See

Nov 15, 2024 | Entertainment and Arts

By: Russ Matthews

For teachers, there is a vindication of the classic children’s literature of the past, when it becomes source material for a modern cinematic release.

These well-loved books may be dog-eared and discoloured as they sit on the shelves of the local school library, but a great story can stand the test of time. Director Dallas Jenkins (The Chosen) has reached back through the generations to rediscover Barbara Robinson’s beloved Christmas tale that has as much to say now as it did upon release in 1972.

The voice of Elizabeth “Beth” Bradley (Molly Belle Wright/Lauren Graham) narrates this story of the Christmas season when her mother, Grace (Judy Greer), volunteered to direct the church pageant. A traditional production that went back generations was in jeopardy as the former director was injured and had to hand over the responsibilities. A task that seems to be straightforward for anyone to take on until The Herdman’s decide they want to be in the play of Jesus’ birth. The Herdmans are a group of delinquent siblings who are tyrannical at the local primary school and have never been to church. That was until they were unexpectedly invited to attend by Beth’s younger brother, Charlie (Sebastian Billingsley-Rodriguez). All looks to be a disaster until the siblings discover the fascinating history behind the story of this baby born in the manger.

As this classic comedy-turned-heartwarming narrative about people’s need for the message of Jesus’ birth unfolds on screen, Barbara Robinson’s tale shows how it transcends time. Dallas Jenkins keeps the storyline in the same era as the book was originally written, which helps to make the whole thing believable. There are no modern distractions, and the nostalgic elements will make this appealing to multiple generations. Yet, the setting does translate effectively to the big screen and will capture the hearts of today’s viewers while offering a wonderful cinematic choice for the Christmas season.

Jenkins’ vision is picturesque, and the dialogue is faithful to the original material. The writing does embrace the absurdness of the terror the Herdman’s have on the town and allows the beauty of the story to unfold. The screenplay exposes the heart of the community and the transcendently transformative message of Jesus’ birth can have on those who really study it. While all of the cast make ideal choices for each character, the performances of Beatrice Schneider (Imogene Herdman), Judy Greer and Molly Belle Wright deliver the emotional aspects of this cherished children’s book that will entertain everyone in the family.

The Best Christmas Pageant Ever is a must-see for the Christmas season and will need to be on regular repeat for years to come. Dallas Jenkins shows how this story is a gift worth unpacking in cinemas that will bring the family together like no other film on offer during the holidays.

What opportunity will parents have after The Best Christmas Pageant Ever?

The Best Christmas Pageant Ever is a perfect opportunity for parents to talk with their children about the real meaning of Christmas. The birth of the Saviour of the world, Jesus.

Barbara Robinson’s story is a beautiful expression of how wonderfully transformative this annual retelling can still change lives. This is one of those unexpected family films that will touch anyone’s heart who is willing to give it a listen.

For those looking to learn more about the story, go to Jesus’ biography in Luke.

If you would like to discuss the themes of this film, contact us at Third Space. We would love to chat with you about this and more.


Article supplied with thanks to City Bible Forum.

All images: Movie publicity

About the author: Russ Matthews is a film critic at City Bible Forum and Reel Dialogue. He has a passion for film and sparking spiritual conversations.

[adrotate group="2"]
[adrotate group="4"]
[adrotate group="3"]